12 Tasty Things to Make From Scratch and Save Money

Feeling the pinch of higher food prices? Here are a dozen items to make from scratch. You’ll save money and avoid food waste!

Jars of homemade instant oatmeal sit on a white counter. They contain nuts and dried fruit.
Homemade instant oatmeal is easy to make with the toppings you like best.

I can’t be the only one who has recently stood in a grocery store aisle, done a double-take on a price, and blurted out “Are you kidding me?!?”

Grocery prices are up–by more than 10 percent over last year, according to government statistics.

Though that price hike has probably changed what and how much you buy each week, unfortunately it hasn’t changed your family’s appetites.

They still want to be fed. All. The. Time.

So what can you make from scratch?

It may seem like a no-brainer that making more things from scratch could ease the pain of higher prices.

But which items actually save you real money?

To find out, Real Mom Nutrition team member Cheryll crunched allll the numbers, figuring out the costs down to the spices and seasonings.

Some items we figured would be slam-dunk money-savers actually weren’t (hello, homemade salad dressing).

Others were way cheaper than even we thought (we’re looking at you, DIY sushi rolls and Starbucks copy cat drink!).

Below are the ones that came out on top, along with price comparisons.

It goes without saying, but…

  • Costs for ingredients are based on local prices, and those may vary by region.
  • You have a life away from the kitchen and your time has value too. Some from-scratch items will feel worth it to you, but some won’t. And that’s okay!

Make From Scratch: Money Savers


Make Ahead Breakfast Sandwiches made with egg, cheese, and bacon sit on a silver baking sheet on a wood table.
Assemble breakfast sandwiches on the weekend for hearty meals all week long.

Breakfast Sandwiches

  • Frozen Jimmy Dean breakfast sandwiches: $2.00 each
  • Homemade breakfast sandwiches: 88 cents each

These sandwiches are freezer heroes. They’re energizing morning meals and hearty after-school snacks, and they can even pinch-hit for dinner on busy nights. Not to mention, they’re easy to assemble and hold up well in the deep freeze. Get the complete how-to: Make-Ahead Breakfast Sandwiches


Homemade bagels sit on a wire cooling rack in front of a bread machine. Some are topped with sesame seeds, some with poppyseeds.
Homemade bagels are easier to make than you might think!

Homemade Bagels

  • Panera bagel: $1.79 each
  • Homemade bagel: 32 cents each

I promise it’s easier than you think to make your own soft, chewy homemade bagels. They’re so much better than store-bought–and so much cheaper than the bakery. Add the toppings your gang likes best. I have an easy-to-follow, step-by-step recipe, including a short-cut if you have a bread machine.


Simple Cucumber Sushi Rolls made with carrots and cucumbers and white rice are sitting on a green plate. A hand holds one piece in chopsticks over a bowl of soy sauce.
Homemade veggie sushi is a fraction of the cost of store-bought.

Simple Sushi Rolls

  • Order of veggie sushi rolls: $5.95 each
  • Homemade veggie sushi rolls: $1.00 each

This recipe for easy sushi rolls is perfect for beginners and a great project for kids. It’s also a nice way to fit some extra veggies in everyone’s day. Feel free to tuck some sliced avocado in there too. Get the recipe and how-to: Simple Veggie Sushi Rolls


Making homemade guacamole. A striped bowl holds the inside of two avocados being smashed with a potato masher.
This homemade guacamole gets rave reviews!

Guacamole

  • 16 oz. brand-name store-bought guacamole: $7.99
  • 16 oz. homemade guacamole: $3.20

This guacamole recipe couldn’t be easier with just four simple ingredients, but it almost always gets compliments when I bring it to a party. I think that’s because the simple, fresh flavors really shine through. One of my son’s friends even called it “better than Chipotle’s”. Get the recipe: No-Fuss Guacamole


A white bowl of homemade hummus sits on a wood tray with carrots, crackers, cucumbers, and peppers.
One whirl of the blender or food processor = nutritious, affordable snack.

Hummus

  • Brand-name store-bought hummus: 45 cents/ounce
  • Homemade hummus: 11 cents/ounce

Homemade hummus is as easy as pushing a button on your blender or food processor. Skip the store-bought version for the fresher flavor of making it yourself. Get the recipe for Very Lemony Homemade Hummus


A bowl of Homemade Baked Tortilla Chips sits on a wood table in front of a bowl of salsa and a stack of corn tortillas.
Homemade corn tortilla chips

Corn Tortilla Chips

  • Tostitos Yellow Corn Chips: 42 cents/ounce
  • Homemade Corn Chips: 6 cents/ounce

All you need are three ingredients to make a batch of homemade baked tortilla chips. They’re so much crunchier and heartier than the bagged kind, which now seem flimsy and inadequate next to these substantial wedges, especially delicious when served warm and fresh. Get the recipe: Homemade Corn Tortilla Chips


A pitcher of homemade sports drink sits in front of a red water bottle, two lemons, and a glass bottle of lemonade, all on a wood table.
Take a bottle of homemade sports drink to the sidelines.

Sports Drink

  • Gatorade Lemon Drink: 6 cents/ounce
  • Homemade Sports Drink: 1 cent/ounce

Yes, sports drinks are overused, especially in typical youth rec sports. But some young athletes do need what a sports drink provides, especially if they’re exercising for long periods of time. Avoid the synthetic food dyes, artificial flavors, stabilizers, and other stuff in commercial sports drinks by making your own lemon-flavored electrolyte beverage with just a few simple ingredients. Get the recipe: Homemade Sports Drink


A red mug of Copy Cat Starbucks Vanilla Steamer overflowing with whipped cream sits on a white napkin alongside a green mug of vanilla steamer.
Make a favorite decaf drink yourself and save serious bucks.

Copy Cat Vanilla Steamer

  • Grande Starbucks Vanilla Steamer: $3.75
  • Homemade Copycat Vanilla Steamer: $1.53

The Starbucks Vanilla Steamer is one of my favorite cold-weather splurges. It’s also a drink young kids can enjoy, since it’s coffee-free and caffeine-free. I started making these a few years ago when it occurred to me that I could treat myself (for a lot less money) at home. Get the recipe: Copy Cat Starbucks Vanilla Steamer


Make From Scratch: Waste Busters

Do you get a rush when you repurpose odds and ends from the fridge and pantry instead of wasting them? Me too. These recipes are just what we all need to feel like kitchen magicians.


A frosted Pyrex measuring cup holds an array of colorful Homemade Fruit Popsicles
DIY Otter Pops!

Ice Pops

It’s the perfect way to clear out the fruit drawer, especially when items are nearing past-their-prime status. Instead of wasting that fruit, whirl it in a blender with a touch of honey to make homemade ice pops (the honey keeps them sort of slushy). Pour them into these fun ice pop pouches or these reusable molds. Get the recipe: 2-Ingredient Fruit Popsicles


A small glass jar of yogurt topped with homemade granola and blueberries sits on a white counter in front of a larger jar of granola and two jars of ingredients: brown sugar and oats.
This simple granola uses up your pantry odds and ends.

Granola

It’s just the thing for half-empty bags of nuts and seeds taking up space in your pantry and freezer. In just one hour of prep, you’ll have breakfasts, snacks, and yogurt toppings for the next week or more.


An array of colorful Homemade Yogurt Tubes sits on a white countertop.
Yogurt tubes can be refrigerated or frozen.

Yogurt Tubes

A little bit of yogurt + a little bit of fruit + a splash of milk = DIY yogurt tubes that are fun fresh or frozen and deliver calcium, potassium, protein, and vitamin D in each tube. Get the recipe: Homemade Yogurt Tubes


Jars of homemade instant oatmeal sit on a white counter. They contain nuts and dried fruit.
You can keep DIY oatmeal packets in baggies or jars.

DIY Oatmeal Packets

If you’ve got some instant oats and tasty mix-ins, you can make your own healthy instant oatmeal packets in about 10 minutes. Pack it up in baggies, jars, or other containers. Here’s a simple how-to: Healthy Instant Oatmeal Packets

Similar Posts